When you think of Islamorada, you think of crystal-clear waters, endless horizons, and some of the best fishing opportunities in the world. Known as the “Sportfishing Capital of the World,” this Florida Keys gem draws anglers from every corner of the globe, from beginners to seasoned pros.
Whether you’re after the adrenaline rush of offshore big game or the quiet joy of reef fishing, Islamorada has it all.
Let’s dive into the top 10 fishing spots in Islamorada, starting with the iconic Robbie’s of Islamorada!
10 Best Places to Fish in Islamorada
10. Local Shorelines and Bridges
While our list is packed with fantastic charters and iconic spots, Islamorada’s accessible shorelines and bridges deserve a mention. Spots like the Tea Table Relief Bridge and Channel 2 Bridge offer excellent opportunities for anglers looking to cast a line without boarding a boat.
These areas are perfect for catching snapper, tarpon, and jacks, especially during the early morning or late evening hours. Plus, you can enjoy the beauty of the Keys at your own pace.
9. Blue Chip Too Charters
Operated by the legendary Captain Skip Bradeen, Blue Chip Too Charters is a fixture in the Islamorada fishing community. With decades of experience, Captain Skip knows exactly where the fish are and how to get you there fast.
From deep-sea sportfishing to family-friendly reef trips, you’ll enjoy a day filled with excitement and local storytelling. The boat is spacious and comfortable, making it perfect for full-day adventures.
8. Miller Time Sportfishing
For those looking for a dedicated, no-nonsense fishing trip, Miller Time Sportfishing delivers. Captain Patrick Miller is well-known in Islamorada for his deep local knowledge and dedication to providing productive trips.
You’ll head offshore in pursuit of mahi-mahi, sailfish, tuna, or head to the reefs for snapper and grouper. With their well-equipped boat and friendly crew, every outing feels like fishing with friends who just happen to be experts.
7. LegaSea Charters
LegaSea Charters offers tailored fishing experiences for every angler. Whether you’re dreaming of offshore action or a quiet day exploring backcountry waters, their knowledgeable captains will customize your trip.
Their charters are particularly popular for targeting species like permit, bonefish, tarpon, and snook. Plus, they place a strong emphasis on conservation and sustainable fishing, ensuring that these waters stay pristine for future generations.
6. Alligator Reef
For those who want to mix incredible fishing with breathtaking views, Alligator Reef is a must-visit. Just a few miles offshore, this iconic lighthouse marks one of the most vibrant reef systems in the area.
You’ll find snapper, grouper, barracuda, and even the occasional shark. The clear turquoise waters make it ideal not only for fishing but also for snorkeling before or after your angling adventure. Alligator Reef offers the perfect combination of action and scenery.
Pro Tip: Bring a waterproof camera, you’ll want to capture the beauty of this spot
5. Florida Keys Fun Fishing
As the name suggests, Florida Keys Fun Fishing is all about enjoying the experience. These charters focus on family-friendly trips and a relaxed atmosphere without compromising the quality of fishing.
You can explore the shallow waters of Florida Bay, where snook, tarpon, and redfish are plentiful. The captains love helping guests discover the beauty of the Keys’ marine life, and their enthusiasm is contagious. This is a great option if you want a trip that blends fishing with sightseeing.
4. Fearless Fishing Charters
If you’re chasing that adrenaline rush of offshore sportfishing, Fearless Fishing Charters is a top contender. Captain Joey is renowned for putting anglers on big fish fast, and you’ll appreciate the hands-on guidance and local expertise.
Expect to encounter mahi-mahi, sailfish, tuna, and wahoo depending on the season. Fearless Fishing Charters is perfect for anglers looking for a high-energy day on the water with great odds of landing serious game fish.
3. Bud N’ Mary’s Marina
A legendary spot, Bud N’ Mary’s Marina has been a cornerstone of the Islamorada fishing scene since the 1940s. Known for their fleet of seasoned captains and an impressive variety of boats, they offer everything from offshore sportfishing to wreck and reef trips.
What makes Bud N’ Mary’s special is its rich history and the passionate community that surrounds it. It’s the perfect place if you’re aiming for sailfish, tuna, or king mackerel. You’ll also find one of the best fish-cleaning tables in the Keys, where you can see pros at work (and maybe grab some tips!).
2. Bamboo Charters
For a personalized fishing adventure, Bamboo Charters delivers every time. Their friendly and experienced captains tailor each trip to your goals, whether it’s sportfishing in the backcountry or exploring the nearby reefs. They specialize in family-friendly charters, so even if you’re bringing along first-time anglers or kids, you’re in excellent hands.
With Bamboo Charters, you’ll likely find snook, redfish, snapper, and more. Plus, they’re great at helping you understand the local ecosystem, making the trip both fun and educational.
1. Robbie’s of Islamorada
If there’s one place you can’t miss, it’s Robbie’s of Islamorada. More than just a marina, Robbie’s is a full-on fishing experience and local treasure. Known widely for the famous tarpon feeding at the docks, Robbie’s is also your gateway to epic fishing adventures.
From here, you can book backcountry trips, deep-sea excursions, or stick around the dock for some fun inshore action. Whether you’re chasing tarpon, snapper, grouper, or mahi-mahi, the captains at Robbie’s know the waters like the back of their hand.
Plus, the lively vibe of the marina, complete with waterfront restaurants, local art stands, and unforgettable sunsets, makes Robbie’s more than just a fishing spot, it’s a full Keys experience.
Pro Tip: Don’t leave without feeding the tarpon! It’s an Islamorada rite of passage.
Conclusion
Islamorada is truly an angler’s paradise. Whether you’re looking for a thrilling offshore battle, a peaceful day in the backcountry, or a family-friendly fishing trip, there’s a perfect spot waiting for you.
From the legendary atmosphere of Robbie’s of Islamorada to the serene beauty of Alligator Reef, each destination on this list offers something unique. Local captains know these waters like their own backyard and are ready to help you create unforgettable memories on the water.
So pack your gear, bring your sense of adventure, and get ready to reel in your next big catch in Islamorada. Tight lines!